Home / Research studies / Calorie app reviews study
What app store reviews say about calorie-tracking apps
In the reviews we counted, money comes up more than any other complaint about calorie-tracking apps. A keyword script counted the App Store and Google Play reviews in our evidence files for five popular trackers, tallying what people praise and what they complain about. Here is the headline.
Price or paywall is the top complaint for every one of the 5 apps. 622 of 2,098 one- and two-star reviews (29.6%) mention it.
Data collected November 6, 2026 to November 17, 2026, from 6,656 reviews written between December 12, 2018 and November 15, 2026. Method.
Which calorie-tracking app do reviewers rate highest?
Carb Manager has the highest mean rating in the study at 4.11 out of 5, and MyFitnessPal the lowest at 2.74. Across all 6,656 reviews from the five apps, the pooled mean is 3.53, so apps with more reviews weigh more. Source: the stored App Store and Google Play reviews linked under “Where do the numbers come from?”, counted as described in the method.
The all-apps mean counts every review equally, so apps with more reviews weigh more. Source: 6,656 App Store and Google Play reviews of 5 apps, collected November 6, 2026 to November 17, 2026. How it was counted.
How do the star ratings split?
Reviewers rarely sit on the fence. Across all 6,656 reviews, 58.8% give four or five stars, 31.5% give one or two, and only 9.6% give three. That is why each app’s average hides two very different groups of users. Source: star counts from the same stored reviews, see the method.
Source: 6,656 App Store and Google Play reviews of 5 apps, collected November 6, 2026 to November 17, 2026. How it was counted.
What do unhappy reviewers complain about?
Money comes first. 622 of the 2,098 one- and two-star reviews (29.6%) fall under price or paywall, meaning they mention the price, a paywall, a subscription, a charge or a refund. Next come the recent update theme (358) and the login or crashes theme (266). Source: keyword counts in the stored low ratings, see the method.
One review can match several themes, so the shares add up to more than the reviews themed. Source: 6,656 App Store and Google Play reviews of 5 apps, collected November 6, 2026 to November 17, 2026. How it was counted.
Our reading: price is the most common complaint in the low ratings, so if you are choosing one, look at the free version and the renewal terms before you pay.
What do happy reviewers praise?
The tracking itself. 1,626 of the 3,916 four- and five-star reviews (41.5%) praise macro tracking, 1,033 (26.4%) praise ease of use, and 401 (10.2%) mention recipes. Source: keyword counts in the stored high ratings, see the method.
Do iPhone and Android users rate the apps differently?
Across all 5 apps, App Store reviewers give a mean of 3.57 from 2,947 reviews, and Google Play reviewers give 3.50 from 3,709. The gap between platforms is small next to the gap between apps, so pick the app first and the platform matters little. Source: the stored reviews split by store, see the method.
Review counts in brackets. Source: 6,656 App Store and Google Play reviews of 5 apps, collected November 6, 2026 to November 17, 2026. How it was counted.
Do ratings change between app versions?
They do move. The table shows, for each app, the biggest move in mean rating between two consecutive versions with at least 30 reviews each. A version’s mean also depends on who happened to review it, so treat a big move as a reason to read that version’s release notes on the store listing, not as proof the update caused it. Source: the stored reviews grouped by the app version they were written on, see the method.
| App | Versions with 30+ reviews | Biggest change between them | Mean rating before and after |
|---|---|---|---|
| Carb Manager | 10 | 12.5.1 to 12.6.0 | 3.65 to 4.59 (+0.94) |
| Cronometer | 13 | 4.54.1 to 4.55.1 | 4.13 to 3.70 (-0.43) |
| MacroFactor | 11 | 5.7.9 to 5.8.3 | 4.27 to 3.68 (-0.59) |
| Eat This Much | 1 | Too few versions with 30+ reviews to compare | |
| MyFitnessPal | 12 | 26.36.0 to 26.37.0 | 2.42 to 3.13 (+0.71) |
Mean rating per app version, App Store and Google Play combined, for versions with at least 30 reviews; versions are ordered by version number, and a change is the difference between consecutive versions with at least 30 reviews. Source: 6,656 App Store and Google Play reviews of 5 apps, collected November 6, 2026 to November 17, 2026. How it was counted.
Which app should you pick?
Our verdict: choose by what you want the app to do, and read the price before you subscribe, since price is the most common complaint in low ratings.
- Keto or low carb: Carb Manager. It is our top keto pick, and the full review has the detail.
- Vitamin and mineral detail, or a web version: Cronometer. See the full review.
- A macro tracker reviewers call easy to use: MacroFactor, if the price does not put you off. See the full review.
- Meals planned for you: Eat This Much. See the full review.
- Already on MyFitnessPal: stay only if it works for you; its reviewers rate it lowest in this study. See the full review.
Here are the five side by side, with prices from each vendor’s pricing page checked November 21, 2026. Tap an app name to go to its store page and start with the free download.
| App | Price | Free tier | Platforms | Reviews analyzed | Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Carb Manager | $8.49 a month, $39.99 a year, checked Nov 21, 2026 | Not listed | ios, android | 1141 (as of 2026-11-06) | |
| Cronometer | $10.99 a month, $59.99 a year, checked Nov 21, 2026 | Not listed | ios, android, web | 1407 (as of 2026-11-06) | Best for detailed micronutrient tracking |
| MacroFactor | $11.99 a month, $71.99 a year, checked Nov 21, 2026 | Not listed | ios, android | 1181 (as of 2026-11-17) | |
| Eat This Much | $14.99 a month, $59.99 a year, checked Nov 21, 2026 | Not listed | ios, android, web | 1105 (as of 2026-11-12) | Best for meal plans built from macro targets |
| MyFitnessPal | $19.99 a month, $79.99 a year, checked Nov 21, 2026 | Not listed | ios, android | 1822 (as of 2026-11-06) |
How was the study done?
We counted public App Store and Google Play reviews for five calorie and macro tracking apps, collected by script into our evidence files and summarized with AI assistance. William set the criteria and checked the page. We do not test apps by hand.
| App | App Store reviews | Google Play reviews | Total | Reviews written | Release notes | Collected |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Carb Manager | 515 | 626 | 1,141 | Jan 24, 2025 to Nov 5, 2026 | 26 | Nov 6, 2026 |
| Cronometer | 589 | 818 | 1,407 | May 22, 2026 to Nov 5, 2026 | 29 | Nov 6, 2026 |
| MacroFactor | 531 | 650 | 1,181 | Aug 20, 2025 to Nov 15, 2026 | 27 | Nov 17, 2026 |
| Eat This Much | 501 | 604 | 1,105 | Dec 12, 2018 to Nov 11, 2026 | 26 | Nov 12, 2026 |
| MyFitnessPal | 811 | 1,011 | 1,822 | Aug 14, 2026 to Nov 5, 2026 | 29 | Nov 6, 2026 |
| All 5 apps | 2,947 | 3,709 | 6,656 | Dec 12, 2018 to Nov 15, 2026 | 137 | Nov 17, 2026 |
How themes were counted. Keyword tagging per app, from each evidence file's themes block: a review matches a theme if its title or text contains any keyword in that theme's list below. Praise themes are counted in 4- and 5-star reviews, complaint themes in 1- and 2-star reviews; 3-star reviews are not themed, and one review can match several themes. Pooled counts are the sum across apps.
| Theme | Keywords (any match counts) |
|---|---|
| Praise themes (4- and 5-star reviews) | |
| Macro tracking | macro, calorie, protein, track |
| Ease of use | easy to use, easy, simple, intuitive, user friendly, user-friendly |
| Recipes | recipe, meals are good, variety, delicious |
| Meal planning | meal plan, planning, plan my, planner, menu |
| Grocery list | grocery, groceries, shopping list |
| Customer support | support, customer service, responsive, helpful team |
| Complaint themes (1- and 2-star reviews) | |
| Price or paywall | price, paywall, subscription, expensive, premium, pay , charge, refund, cost |
| Recent update | update, new version, latest version, since the |
| Login or crashes | login, log in, sign in, crash, freez, won't open, wont open, bug, glitch, not working, doesn't work |
| Repetitive or odd meals | repetitive, same meal, same thing, repeat, weird, odd , strange, unrealistic, random |
| Sync problems | sync, syncing, not saving, lost my, disappear |
| Food exclusions | exclude, exclusion, allerg, dislike, vegetarian, vegan, gluten, dairy, ingredient i |
How version changes were counted. Mean rating per app version, App Store and Google Play combined, for versions with at least 30 reviews; versions are ordered by version number, and a change is the difference between consecutive versions with at least 30 reviews.
Limits. Each app’s sample is the set of recent reviews the stores returned when we collected them, so the date ranges differ by app (see the table). The pooled figures count every review equally, and MyFitnessPal contributes the most reviews (27.4% of the total), so they lean towards it. Store reviews lean towards very happy and very unhappy users. Keyword counts miss a review that describes a problem in other words, and they can count a review that uses a keyword in passing. We did not analyze Reddit, because its robots.txt disallows automated collection. The full method is on the how we research page.
How should I cite this study?
Use this wording, and link to the page so readers can check the counts:
Plate Scales. "What app store reviews say about calorie-tracking apps". Data collected November 6, 2026 to November 17, 2026. https://platescales.com/research/calorie-app-reviews/
In a sentence: "Price or paywall is the most common complaint about calorie-tracking apps: 622 of 2,098 one- and two-star reviews of 5 apps mention it, according to a Plate Scales analysis of 6,656 App Store and Google Play reviews."
Canonical URL: https://platescales.com/research/calorie-app-reviews/
Where can I read more?
What are the most common questions?
What do people complain about most in calorie-tracking apps?
Price and paywalls. It is the most common theme in the one- and two-star reviews of the apps in this study, and the complaint chart on this page shows the count and share for each theme.
Which calorie-tracking app do reviewers rate highest?
The rating chart near the top of this page ranks the apps by mean star rating, from the stored App Store and Google Play reviews. The study page updates when the review data is refreshed, so the chart is the current answer.
Do iPhone and Android users rate these apps differently?
The study compares the mean App Store rating with the mean Google Play rating for each app. The platform chart shows both, with the number of reviews behind each figure.
How were the review themes counted?
By keyword. A review counts toward a theme when its title or text contains one of that theme’s keywords. Praise themes are counted in four- and five-star reviews and complaint themes in one- and two-star reviews.
Can I use these numbers in my own article?
Yes. Quote the figures with a link to this page, using the suggested wording in the citation box, and include the collection dates so readers know how current the counts are.
Did Plate Scales test the apps?
No, we do not test apps by hand. This study counts what store reviewers wrote, and it was researched with AI assistance and checked by William.
Does Plate Scales earn money from these apps?
Some apps run affiliate programs, listed on our disclosure page. The study counts every app the same way, and payout plays no part in the numbers.
Where do the numbers come from?
- Carb Manager on the App Store (listing, reviews, release notes)
- Carb Manager on Google Play (listing, reviews)
- Cronometer on the App Store (listing, reviews, release notes)
- Cronometer on Google Play (listing, reviews)
- MacroFactor on the App Store (listing, reviews, release notes)
- MacroFactor on Google Play (listing, reviews)
- Eat This Much on the App Store (listing, reviews, release notes)
- Eat This Much on Google Play (listing, reviews)
- MyFitnessPal on the App Store (listing, reviews, release notes)
- MyFitnessPal on Google Play (listing, reviews)
Updates log. November 17, 2026: Study figures refreshed from the 2026-11-17 MacroFactor evidence (1,181 reviews); all numbers come from data/study/app_reviews.json. November 12, 2026: Study figures refreshed from the 2026-11-12 Eat This Much evidence (1,105 reviews); all numbers come from data/study/app_reviews.json. November 10, 2026: Study drafted from the evidence files.