Home / Comparisons / MacroFactor vs Carb Manager: Carb Manager wins in 2,322 store reviews
MacroFactor vs Carb Manager: Carb Manager wins in 2,322 store reviews
Which app wins?
MacroFactor
Carb Manager wins: a 4.11 mean rating against MacroFactor's 3.77 across 1,141 and 1,181 reviews, price comes up in 30.5% of its one- and two-star reviews against 38.8% for MacroFactor, and it lists the lower price on both plans.
- Overall: Carb Manager
- Keto and low-carb tracking: Carb Manager
- Lower price: Carb Manager
- Fewer paywall complaints: Carb Manager
- Recipes: Carb Manager
- Praise for macro tracking: MacroFactor
- Fewer login and crash complaints: MacroFactor
How do Carb Manager and MacroFactor compare?
| App | Price | Free tier | Platforms | Reviews analyzed | Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Carb Manager | $8.49 a month, $39.99 a year, checked Nov 21, 2026 | Not listed | ios, android | 1141 (as of 2026-11-06) | |
| MacroFactor | $11.99 a month, $71.99 a year, checked Nov 21, 2026 | Not listed | ios, android | 1181 (as of 2026-11-17) |
Which should you pick?
Carb Manager wins the MacroFactor vs Carb Manager comparison, and it is the one to pick if you want a higher-rated tracker that costs less. Pick MacroFactor instead if praise for macro tracking matters more to you than the bill. Carb Manager’s reviewers give it a mean of 4.11 against 3.77 for MacroFactor, and 870 four- and five-star reviews against 788, from 1,141 and 1,181 reviews. Money still decides a lot of the unhappy reviews on both sides: price, the paywall or a subscription comes up in 38.8% of MacroFactor’s one- and two-star reviews and 30.5% of Carb Manager’s. Source: Carb Manager reviews on the App Store and Google Play, collected November 6, 2026, MacroFactor reviews on the App Store and Google Play, collected November 17, 2026.
MacroFactor is not the weaker app in every way. Its fans praise macro tracking more often, and fewer of its unhappy reviewers blame logging in or crashes. If those matter more to you than the bill, it is a good pick.
What does each app cost?
Carb Manager costs less on both plans. Both prices are in the verdict box above, checked November 21, 2026 for Carb Manager on its own pricing page and November 21, 2026 for MacroFactor on its App Store subscription listing, both linked in the sources below. On either app the annual plan is the better deal. Our product file lists a free trial for MacroFactor and no confirmed free tier or free trial for Carb Manager, so check the sign-up screen before you subscribe.
The paywall bothers MacroFactor’s reviewers more. Of its 309 one- and two-star reviews, 120 (38.8%) mention the price, the paywall or a subscription, against 61 of 200 (30.5%) for Carb Manager. Source: Carb Manager reviews on the App Store and Google Play, collected November 6, 2026, MacroFactor reviews on the App Store and Google Play, collected November 17, 2026.
Which app wins for what?
Our verdict for each use, with the counts behind it. Source: the store review pages for both apps, collected November 6 and November 17, 2026, the pricing sources below and our product file.
- Overall: Carb Manager. A mean of 4.11 against 3.77, 870 positive reviews against 788, and the lower price.
- Keto and low-carb: Carb Manager. 99 of its 1,141 reviews mention keto, against 2 of 1,181.
- Lower price: Carb Manager. Both its plans cost less, checked November 21, 2026.
- Fewer paywall complaints: Carb Manager. Price comes up in 30.5% of its low ratings against 38.8%.
- Recipes: Carb Manager. 97 of 870 positive reviews (11.1%) mention recipes, against 45 of 788 (5.7%).
- Praise for macro tracking: MacroFactor. 413 of 788 positive reviews (52.4%) mention macros, calories, protein or tracking, against 359 of 870 (41.3%).
- Fewer login and crash complaints: MacroFactor. 22 of its 309 low ratings (7.1%) against 26 of 200 (13.0%).


How do reviewers rate them?
Both lean positive, and Carb Manager leans further. Of 1,141 Carb Manager reviews, 870 (76.2%) gave four or five stars and 200 (17.5%) gave one or two. Of 1,181 MacroFactor reviews, 788 (66.7%) gave four or five stars and 309 (26.2%) gave one or two. Source: Carb Manager reviews on the App Store and Google Play, collected November 6, 2026, MacroFactor reviews on the App Store and Google Play, collected November 17, 2026.
| Stars | Carb Manager | MacroFactor |
|---|---|---|
| 5 | 743 (65.1%) | 668 (56.6%) |
| 4 | 127 (11.1%) | 120 (10.2%) |
| 3 | 71 (6.2%) | 84 (7.1%) |
| 2 | 57 (5.0%) | 76 (6.4%) |
| 1 | 143 (12.5%) | 233 (19.7%) |
| Mean | 4.11 | 3.77 |
| Source | App Store, Google Play, collected November 6, 2026 | App Store, Google Play, collected November 17, 2026 |
Carb Manager’s sample is 1,141 reviews (515 App Store, 626 Google Play) and MacroFactor’s is 1,181 reviews (531 App Store, 650 Google Play). The Carb Manager sample runs from January 24, 2025 to November 4, 2026 on the App Store and from November 25, 2025 to November 5, 2026 on Google Play, across 27 app versions. The MacroFactor sample runs from August 20, 2025 to November 14, 2026 on the App Store and from January 22, 2026 to November 15, 2026 on Google Play, across 37 app versions. Source: the store review pages linked in the table; see How we research.
One thing to weigh: the MacroFactor reviews were collected eleven days after the Carb Manager reviews, and both samples reach back more than a year on the App Store. Store reviews also lean towards very happy and very unhappy users, so read these as what reviewers said, not what every user thinks.
What do reviewers love about each app?
Both sets of fans talk about tracking and ease of use, and MacroFactor’s talk about tracking more often. We counted themes by keyword tagging: a review matches a theme when its title or text contains one of the theme’s keywords, praise counts come from four- and five-star reviews, and one review can match more than one theme. Source: the store review pages linked in the table.
| Praise theme | Carb Manager (of 870) | MacroFactor (of 788) |
|---|---|---|
| Macro tracking (macros, calories, protein, tracking) | 359 (41.3%) | 413 (52.4%) |
| Ease of use (easy, simple, intuitive, user friendly) | 260 (29.9%) | 245 (31.1%) |
| Recipes (recipes, variety, delicious) | 97 (11.1%) | 43 (5.8%) |
| Customer support (support, customer service, responsive) | 13 (1.5%) | 19 (2.4%) |
| Meal planning (meal plans, planning, planner, menu) | 10 (1.1%) | 8 (1.0%) |
| Grocery list (groceries, shopping list) | 0 (0.0%) | 1 (0.1%) |
| Source | App Store, Google Play, collected November 6, 2026 | App Store, Google Play, collected November 17, 2026 |
Carb Manager’s own site says its Premium version lets you log food by snapping a picture and describes a premium database of keto recipes, so those features sit behind the paid plan. Source: the vendor home page, read in our product file as of November 10, 2026.
What do reviewers complain about?
Money tops both lists, by a wider margin for MacroFactor; Carb Manager’s unhappy reviewers complain more about logging in, crashes and sync. The same keyword method applied to one- and two-star reviews gives these themes. Source: the store review pages linked in the table.
| Complaint theme | Carb Manager (of 200) | MacroFactor (of 309) |
|---|---|---|
| Price or paywall (price, paywall, subscription, premium, charges, refunds, cost) | 61 (30.5%) | 120 (38.8%) |
| Login or crashes (logging in, crashes, freezing, bugs) | 26 (13.0%) | 22 (7.1%) |
| Recent update (update, new version, latest version) | 13 (6.5%) | 15 (4.9%) |
| Sync or lost data (sync, not saving, lost entries) | 5 (2.5%) | 3 (1.0%) |
| Repetitive or odd meals (repetitive, same meal, odd, random) | 4 (2.0%) | 11 (3.6%) |
| Food exclusions (exclusions, allergies, disliked foods) | 2 (1.0%) | 0 (0.0%) |
| Source | App Store, Google Play, collected November 6, 2026 | App Store, Google Play, collected November 17, 2026 |
What changed recently?
The Carb Manager App Store listing shows version 12.7.0, with a release note dated October 27, 2026 saying Fitbit now syncs through Google Health. The MacroFactor listing shows version 5.8.12, dated November 11, 2026, with a release note that lists bug fixes and performance improvements. The version history holds 26 release notes for Carb Manager and 27 for MacroFactor (Carb Manager back to December 12, 2023, MacroFactor back to October 19, 2025). This page does not chart every release. Source: the App Store listings (first, second, in the order described above), collected November 6 and November 17, 2026.
Weighing other trackers? See how the winner does against the biggest incumbent and for nutrient detail, or how the runner-up does for most people. Want the full picture on the winner? Read our full review of that app.
How did we research this comparison?
The counts on this page come from public App Store and Google Play reviews, the App Store release notes and the store listings, collected and sorted with AI assistance and checked against the evidence files. We do not test apps by hand. We did not analyze Reddit or forum threads, because Reddit blocks automated collection. The full method is on the how we research page.
Our bias. Our product file lists no affiliate program for either app, and no affiliate link is live on this page. The winner comes from the review evidence. See the affiliate disclosure.
What is our recommendation?
Go with Carb Manager if you want a higher-rated tracker that costs less, especially if you eat low carb or keto. Download it, log a few days, and take the annual plan if you stick with it. If reviewers’ praise for macro tracking matters more to you than the extra cost, try MacroFactor instead and use its free trial before you pay.
Where can I read more?
What are the most common questions?
MacroFactor vs Carb Manager: which should you choose?
Choose Carb Manager if you want the higher-rated, cheaper app; its mean rating is 4.11 against 3.77 and price comes up in 30.5% of its low ratings against 38.8% for MacroFactor. Choose MacroFactor if you want the app reviewers praise most for macro tracking (52.4% of its positive reviews against 41.3%) and you accept the higher price.
Is Carb Manager better than MacroFactor?
For most people, yes. Carb Manager’s mean rating is 4.11 against MacroFactor’s 3.77, from 1,141 and 1,181 App Store and Google Play reviews, and 76.2% of its reviews give four or five stars against 66.7%.
Which is cheaper, MacroFactor or Carb Manager?
Carb Manager, on both the monthly and the annual plan. Both prices are in the verdict box, checked November 21, 2026 for Carb Manager and November 21, 2026 for MacroFactor. Our product file lists a free trial for MacroFactor and no confirmed free tier or free trial for Carb Manager, so check the sign-up screen before you pay.
Which is better for keto?
Carb Manager. 99 of its 1,141 reviews mention keto, 84 of them with four or five stars, against 2 of MacroFactor’s 1,181. Counts are keyword matches in reviews collected November 6 and November 17, 2026.
What do MacroFactor reviewers complain about most?
Of 309 one- and two-star reviews, 120 mention the price, the paywall or a subscription, 22 mention logging in, crashes or bugs, and 15 mention an update. Counts are keyword matches, so one review can count under more than one theme.
What do Carb Manager reviewers complain about most?
Of 200 one- and two-star reviews, 61 mention the price, the paywall or a subscription, 26 mention logging in, crashes or bugs, and 13 mention an update. The same keyword method was used for both apps.
Which has better recipes?
Carb Manager. 97 of its 870 positive reviews (11.1%) mention recipes or meal variety, against 45 of 788 (5.7%) for MacroFactor. Its own site describes a premium recipe database, so the recipes sit behind the paid plan.
Did Plate Scales test either app?
No, we do not test apps by hand. This page reports what store reviews, release notes and the store listings say, with counts.
Does Plate Scales earn money from this page?
Our product file lists no affiliate program for either app, and no affiliate link is live on this page. The winner comes from the review evidence, not from commission.
Where do the numbers come from?
- Carb Manager on the App Store (listing, reviews, release notes, screenshots), accessed November 6, 2026
- Carb Manager on Google Play (listing, reviews), accessed November 6, 2026
- MacroFactor on the App Store (listing, reviews, release notes, screenshots), accessed November 17, 2026
- MacroFactor on Google Play (listing, reviews), accessed November 17, 2026
- Carb Manager Premium pricing page, accessed November 21, 2026
- MacroFactor subscription prices on the App Store, accessed November 21, 2026
Updates log. November 13, 2026: Page drafted from store reviews: Carb Manager (1,141) collected November 6, 2026 and MacroFactor (1,100) collected October 15, 2026. November 17, 2026: MacroFactor figures refreshed to the 2026-11-17 evidence (1,181 reviews). Winner unchanged.