Plate Scales

Home / Best for / Best MyFitnessPal alternatives: Carb Manager first, in 4,834 store reviews

Best MyFitnessPal alternatives: Carb Manager first, in 4,834 store reviews

By William. Published . Updated .

Researched with AI assistance from 4,834 App Store and Google Play reviews across 257 versions and 108 release notes. Counts as of November 17, 2026. Last updated November 2026.

What is the verdict?

Our pick is Carb Manager. Its reviewers rate it highest of the four (a 4.11 mean, against 2.74 for MyFitnessPal), it lists the lowest price, and fewer of its unhappy reviewers mention the paywall than MacroFactor's do. Pick Cronometer second if you want nutrient detail, a web version and the fewest price complaints, MacroFactor third for praise on macro tracking, and Eat This Much fourth if you want meal plans.

  • Best overall: Carb Manager
  • Best for nutrient detail and web: Cronometer
  • Best for macro tracking: MacroFactor
  • Best for meal plans: Eat This Much

Carb Manager: $8.49 a month, $39.99 a year, checked Nov 21, 2026

Cronometer: $10.99 a month, $59.99 a year, checked Nov 21, 2026

MacroFactor: $11.99 a month, $71.99 a year, checked Nov 21, 2026

Eat This Much: $14.99 a month, $59.99 a year, checked Nov 21, 2026

Which apps are best for replacing MyFitnessPal?

AppPriceFree tierPlatformsReviews analyzedVerdict
Carb Manager$8.49 a month, $39.99 a year, checked Nov 21, 2026Not listedios, android1141 (as of 2026-11-06)
Cronometer$10.99 a month, $59.99 a year, checked Nov 21, 2026Not listedios, android, web1407 (as of 2026-11-06)Best for detailed micronutrient tracking
MacroFactor$11.99 a month, $71.99 a year, checked Nov 21, 2026Not listedios, android1181 (as of 2026-11-17)
Eat This Much$14.99 a month, $59.99 a year, checked Nov 21, 2026Not listedios, android, web1105 (as of 2026-11-12)Best for meal plans built from macro targets

Which app is the best MyFitnessPal alternative?

Pick Carb Manager. Its reviewers rate it highest of the four alternatives, with a mean of 4.11 from 1,141 reviews, and it lists the lowest price. MyFitnessPal’s mean is 2.74, and just over half of its reviews (51.4%) give one or two stars. Source: Carb Manager reviews on the App Store and Google Play and MyFitnessPal reviews on the App Store and Google Play, collected November 6, 2026.

Here is the ranking in one glance, with MyFitnessPal as the baseline we are comparing against. Prices sit in the verdict box above, checked November 21, 2026 on each vendor’s pricing page.

RankAppMean ratingFour- and five-star reviewsBest for
1Carb Manager4.11870 of 1,141Overall, keto and low carb, lowest price
2Cronometer3.86960 of 1,407Nutrient detail, web version
3MacroFactor3.77788 of 1,181Praise for macro tracking
4Eat This Much3.54646 of 1,105Meal plans
BaselineMyFitnessPal2.74652 of 1,822Staying put if it works for you

Source: mean ratings and star counts from the store reviews of each app, collected November 6, 2026 for Carb Manager, Cronometer and MyFitnessPal, November 17, 2026 for MacroFactor and November 12, 2026 for Eat This Much; see How we research.

1. Why is Carb Manager our top pick?

Carb Manager has the happiest reviewers and the lowest price. Of 1,141 reviews, 870 (76.2%) give four or five stars and 200 (17.5%) give one or two, for a mean of 4.11. Among the happy reviewers, 359 (41.3%) praise the tracking and 97 (11.1%) mention recipes. Source: reviews on the App Store and Google Play, collected November 6, 2026.

The downside is money. 61 of its 200 one- and two-star reviews (30.5%) mention the price, the paywall or a subscription, so check the renewal settings when you sign up. Source: the same keyword method on the App Store and Google Play reviews, collected November 6, 2026. Our product file lists it on iOS and Android only, so there is no web version. Read the full review, or see our head-to-head comparison.

2. When is Cronometer the better pick?

Choose Cronometer if you want vitamins and minerals, a browser version, or the fewest complaints about price. Of 1,407 reviews, 960 (68.2%) give four or five stars and 319 (22.7%) give one or two, for a mean of 3.86. Price comes up in only 50 of those 319 low ratings (15.7%). Source: reviews on the App Store and Google Play, collected November 6, 2026.

Our product file lists iOS, Android and the web as its platforms, and 46 of its low ratings (14.4%) blame a recent update (same reviews, App Store, collected November 6, 2026). See the full review or the head-to-head comparison.

3. Why is MacroFactor third?

MacroFactor’s fans love its macro tracking, but its paywall draws the most complaints of the four. Of 1,181 reviews, 788 (66.7%) give four or five stars and 309 (26.2%) give one or two, for a mean of 3.77. 413 of the positive reviews (52.4%) mention macros, calories, protein or tracking, the highest share here, but 120 of the 309 low ratings (38.8%) mention the price or the paywall. Source: reviews on the App Store and Google Play, collected November 17, 2026.

Its annual plan is the priciest of the four alternatives. Pick it if tracking quality matters more to you than the bill, and read the full review or the head-to-head comparison first.

4. When does Eat This Much make sense?

Eat This Much is the pick if you want an app to plan your meals for you, not just log them. Of 1,105 reviews, 646 (58.5%) give four or five stars and 334 (30.2%) give one or two, for a mean of 3.54, the lowest of the four. Recipes and variety come up in 176 of the 646 positive reviews (27.2%), far above the other apps. Source: reviews on the App Store and Google Play, collected November 12, 2026; the sample runs from December 12, 2018, so older versions count for more in its figures. Our product file lists iOS, Android and the web. Read the full review for the detail.

Is there a free MyFitnessPal alternative?

Cronometer is the clearest, so check before you commit. MyFitnessPal’s own pricing page says barcode scanning and custom macro goals are not included with a free account. Cronometer’s Gold page lists a barcode scanner and custom macro and micronutrient targets under its free plan, with reports and charts limited to a 7-day window. Eat This Much’s pricing page lists barcode scanning and daily meal plans as free, while week-long plans and the automatic grocery list are paid. For Carb Manager and MacroFactor our product file has no confirmed free features, and MacroFactor lists a free trial. Source: the vendor pricing pages, first, second and third in the order described above, read into our product file as of November 10, 2026.

How were the apps ranked?

We ranked them on four criteria: the mean store rating, the share of one- and two-star reviews, the share of those that mention price, and the listed price. Carb Manager comes first on rating and price. The counts come from public App Store and Google Play reviews, collected and sorted with AI assistance, and the samples cover different periods: Carb Manager’s 1,141 reviews run from January 24, 2025, Cronometer’s 1,407 from May 22, 2026, MacroFactor’s 1,181 from August 20, 2025, Eat This Much’s 1,105 from December 12, 2018 and MyFitnessPal’s 1,822 from August 14, 2026. Source: the store review pages linked above.

Store reviews lean towards very happy and very unhappy users. We do not test apps by hand, and we did not analyze Reddit or forum threads, because Reddit blocks automated collection. The full method is on the how we research page.

Our bias. Cronometer and Eat This Much run affiliate programs on Awin and MyFitnessPal one on Pepperjam, all with terms not yet confirmed and no affiliate link live. Our product file lists no paying program for Carb Manager or MacroFactor, so our top pick earns us nothing. See the affiliate disclosure.

What is our recommendation?

Get Carb Manager if you want to leave MyFitnessPal for a higher-rated, cheaper tracker. Download it, log a few ordinary days, and check the renewal settings before you pay; if you subscribe, take the annual plan. Use the Carb Manager button in the verdict box above to start. If you want nutrient detail or a browser version, pick Cronometer instead.

Where can I read more?

What are the most common questions?

What is the best alternative to MyFitnessPal?

Carb Manager, in our review evidence. Its mean rating is 4.11 against 2.74 for MyFitnessPal, 76.2% of its reviews give four or five stars against 35.8%, and it lists the lowest price of the four alternatives. Counts are from App Store and Google Play reviews collected in October and November 2026.

What is the best free alternative to MyFitnessPal?

Cronometer, though Eat This Much also has free features. MyFitnessPal’s own pricing page says barcode scanning and custom macro goals are not included with a free account, while Cronometer’s Gold page lists a barcode scanner and custom targets for the free plan, with reports limited to a 7-day window. Eat This Much’s pricing page lists barcode scanning and daily meal plans as free, with week-long plans paid, so confirm the free plan at sign-up.

What is a cheaper alternative to MyFitnessPal?

Carb Manager is the cheapest of the four on both the monthly and the annual plan. Cronometer and Eat This Much also list lower annual prices than MyFitnessPal in our product file. Every price is in the verdict box, each with the date it was checked.

Which alternative is best for tracking macros?

MacroFactor, if you go by praise: 413 of its 788 positive reviews (52.4%) mention macros, calories, protein or tracking, against 359 of 870 (41.3%) for Carb Manager and 411 of 960 (42.8%) for Cronometer. Carb Manager still ranks first overall on rating and price.

Why do people leave MyFitnessPal?

Money and updates. Of 936 one- and two-star reviews, 301 mention the price or paywall and 265 mention an update. Counts are keyword matches in reviews collected November 6, 2026.

Which alternative is best for meal plans?

Eat This Much. 176 of its 646 positive reviews (27.2%) mention recipes or meal variety, and our product file lists week-long meal plans and automatic grocery lists as paid features. Its mean rating is lower than the other three, so it ranks fourth overall.

What do Reddit users say about MyFitnessPal alternatives?

We cannot say, because Reddit blocks automated collection and we did not analyze it. Our rankings come from App Store and Google Play reviews, release notes and the store listings.

How did Plate Scales rank these apps?

By four criteria: the mean store rating, the share of one- and two-star reviews, the share of those that mention price, and the listed price. Commission does not set the order, and the top pick is an app that pays us nothing. We do not test apps by hand.

Where do the numbers come from?

Updates log. November 13, 2026: Free-alternative section and FAQ now state Eat This Much's free barcode scanning and daily meal plans, as recorded in the product file on November 10, 2026. November 13, 2026: Page drafted from store reviews: Carb Manager, Cronometer and MyFitnessPal collected November 6, 2026, MacroFactor October 15, 2026 and Eat This Much November 12, 2026. November 17, 2026: MacroFactor figures refreshed to the 2026-11-17 evidence (1,181 reviews). Ranking and picks unchanged.

How we research. We do not test apps by hand. Pages are researched with AI assistance from app store reviews across versions, release notes and vendor documentation, then edited by William. Method.

Affiliate relationship. Plate Scales earns a commission if you subscribe through links marked as sponsored. Rank order comes from the stated criteria, not from payout. Disclosure.

Health. Plate Scales compares tools. It does not give medical or dietary advice. Health disclaimer.