Plate Scales

Home / Comparisons / Carb Manager vs MyFitnessPal: why Carb Manager wins in 2,963 store reviews

Carb Manager vs MyFitnessPal: why Carb Manager wins in 2,963 store reviews

By William. Published . Updated .

Researched with AI assistance from 2,963 App Store and Google Play reviews across 76 versions and 55 release notes. Counts as of November 6, 2026. Last updated November 2026.

Which app wins?

Winner

Carb Manager

MyFitnessPal

Carb Manager wins: a 4.11 mean rating against MyFitnessPal's 2.74 across 1,141 and 1,822 reviews, with 870 four- and five-star reviews to MyFitnessPal's 652 and only 13 of its low ratings mentioning an update, against 265 for MyFitnessPal.

  • Overall: Carb Manager
  • Keto and low-carb tracking: Carb Manager
  • Recipes and ease of use: Carb Manager
  • Lowest listed price: Carb Manager
  • Fewest update complaints: Carb Manager
  • Fewer paywall complaints: Carb Manager

How do Carb Manager and MyFitnessPal compare?

AppPriceFree tierPlatformsReviews analyzedVerdict
Carb Manager$8.49 a month, $39.99 a year, checked Nov 21, 2026Not listedios, android1141 (as of 2026-11-06)
MyFitnessPal$19.99 a month, $79.99 a year, checked Nov 21, 2026Not listedios, android1822 (as of 2026-11-06)

Which should you pick?

Pick Carb Manager. Its reviewers are far happier, it lists the lower price, and its low ratings blame updates much less often. Of 1,141 Carb Manager and 1,822 MyFitnessPal reviews, 870 Carb Manager reviewers gave four or five stars against 652 for MyFitnessPal, and the mean rating is 4.11 against 2.74. Source: Carb Manager reviews on the App Store and Google Play, MyFitnessPal reviews on the App Store and Google Play, collected November 6, 2026.

This is not a close race on the reviews. MyFitnessPal is the bigger name, but its reviewers in the sample are unhappy: 936 of its 1,822 reviews give one or two stars. Stay with it only if you already rely on it. Source: App Store and Google Play reviews, collected November 6, 2026.

What does each app cost?

Carb Manager is the cheaper of the two on both plans. Both prices are in the verdict box above, checked November 21, 2026 on each vendor’s pricing page, linked in the sources below. Carb Manager’s monthly and annual prices are both lower than MyFitnessPal’s, and the annual plan is the better deal on either app. Our product file has no confirmed free tier or free trial for either, so check the sign-up screen before you subscribe.

Cheaper does not mean fewer money complaints in every case. Of Carb Manager’s 200 one- and two-star reviews, 61 (30.5%) mention the price, the paywall or a subscription, against 301 of 936 (32.2%) for MyFitnessPal. Source: Carb Manager reviews on the App Store and Google Play, MyFitnessPal reviews on the App Store and Google Play, collected November 6, 2026.

Which app wins for what?

Our verdict for each use, with the counts behind it. Source: Carb Manager reviews on the App Store and Google Play, MyFitnessPal reviews on the App Store and Google Play, collected November 6, 2026, the App Store listings and our product file.

Barcode scanner over a nutrition label, with a panel showing net carbs, fiber, total carbs, protein, fat and calories against daily targets
The barcode scanner and the net carb and macro summary. Screenshot from the Carb Manager App Store listing, captured October 6, 2026.

How do reviewers rate them?

Carb Manager’s reviewers lean positive; MyFitnessPal’s lean negative. Of 1,141 Carb Manager reviews, 870 (76.2%) gave four or five stars and 200 (17.5%) gave one or two. Of 1,822 MyFitnessPal reviews, 652 (35.8%) gave four or five stars and 936 (51.4%) gave one or two. Source: Carb Manager reviews on the App Store and Google Play, MyFitnessPal reviews on the App Store and Google Play, collected November 6, 2026.

StarsCarb ManagerMyFitnessPal
5743 (65.1%)492 (27.0%)
4127 (11.1%)160 (8.8%)
371 (6.2%)234 (12.8%)
257 (5.0%)256 (14.1%)
1143 (12.5%)680 (37.3%)
Mean4.112.74
Source, collected November 6, 2026App Store, Google PlayApp Store, Google Play

Carb Manager’s sample is 1,141 reviews (515 App Store, 626 Google Play) and MyFitnessPal’s is 1,822 reviews (811 App Store, 1,011 Google Play), collected November 6, 2026. The Carb Manager sample runs from January 24, 2025 to November 4, 2026 on the App Store and from November 25, 2025 to November 5, 2026 on Google Play, across 27 app versions. The MyFitnessPal sample runs from August 14, 2026 to November 4, 2026 on the App Store and from August 26, 2026 to November 5, 2026 on Google Play, across 49 app versions. Source: the store review pages linked in the table; see How we research.

One thing to weigh: Carb Manager’s samples reach back months further, while MyFitnessPal’s reflect only the last three months, so its figures show how reviewers feel about recent releases. Store reviews also lean towards very happy and very unhappy users, so read these as what reviewers said, not what every user thinks.

What do reviewers love about each app?

Tracking is the top praise for both at a similar share; Carb Manager pulls ahead on ease of use and recipes. We counted themes by keyword tagging: a review matches a theme when its title or text contains one of the theme’s keywords, praise counts come from four- and five-star reviews, and one review can match more than one theme. Source: the store review pages linked in the table, collected November 6, 2026; see How we research.

Praise themeCarb Manager (of 870)MyFitnessPal (of 652)
Macro tracking (macros, calories, protein, tracking)359 (41.3%)255 (39.1%)
Ease of use (easy, simple, intuitive, user friendly)260 (29.9%)117 (17.9%)
Recipes (recipes, variety, delicious)97 (11.1%)25 (3.8%)
Customer support (support, customer service, responsive)13 (1.5%)8 (1.2%)
Meal planning (meal plans, planning, planner, menu)10 (1.1%)7 (1.1%)
Source, collected November 6, 2026App Store, Google PlayApp Store, Google Play

What do reviewers complain about?

Both apps draw money complaints; MyFitnessPal also draws far more complaints about updates and crashes. The same keyword method applied to one- and two-star reviews gives these themes. Source: the store review pages linked in the table, collected November 6, 2026.

Complaint themeCarb Manager (of 200)MyFitnessPal (of 936)
Price or paywall (price, paywall, subscription, premium, charges, refunds, cost)61 (30.5%)301 (32.2%)
Login or crashes (logging in, crashes, freezing, bugs)26 (13.0%)150 (16.0%)
Recent update (update, new version, latest version)13 (6.5%)265 (28.3%)
Sync or lost data (sync, not saving, lost entries)5 (2.5%)37 (4.0%)
Source, collected November 6, 2026App Store, Google PlayApp Store, Google Play

What changed recently?

The Carb Manager App Store listing shows version 12.7.0, with a release note dated October 27, 2026 saying Fitbit now syncs through Google Health. The MyFitnessPal listing shows version 26.44.0, dated November 3, 2026, whose note says there are no major feature updates or bugs to report. The version history holds 26 release notes for Carb Manager and 29 for MyFitnessPal (Carb Manager back to December 12, 2023, MyFitnessPal back to May 5, 2026). This page does not chart every release. Source: the App Store listings for Carb Manager (listing) and MyFitnessPal (listing), collected November 6, 2026.

Want another head-to-head? Read a second comparison or see which tracker wins for most people.

How did we research this comparison?

The counts on this page come from public App Store and Google Play reviews, the App Store release notes and the store listings, collected and sorted with AI assistance and checked against the evidence files. We do not test apps by hand. We did not analyze Reddit or forum threads, because Reddit blocks automated collection. The full method is on the how we research page.

Our bias. MyFitnessPal runs an affiliate program on Pepperjam, listed in our product file as a one-off commission for US consumers, with terms not yet confirmed. Our product file lists no paying program for Carb Manager, so it is a referral-only app for us. No affiliate link is live on this page yet. The winner comes from the review evidence, not from the commission. See the affiliate disclosure.

What is our recommendation?

Go with Carb Manager if you count carbs, eat keto or want recipes built into your tracker. It has the happier reviewers, the lower listed price and far fewer update complaints. Download it, log a few days, and only pay once you know you will keep using it, since the paywall is its reviewers’ top complaint. Stay on MyFitnessPal only if you already rely on it and do not want to move your logging history.

Where can I read more?

What are the most common questions?

Is Carb Manager or MyFitnessPal better?

Carb Manager, by a wide margin in the reviews. Its mean rating is 4.11 against MyFitnessPal’s 2.74, from 1,141 and 1,822 App Store and Google Play reviews collected November 6, 2026.

Which is better for keto?

Carb Manager. 99 of its 1,141 reviews mention keto, 84 of them with four or five stars, and none of MyFitnessPal’s 1,822 reviews do. Counts are keyword matches in reviews collected November 6, 2026.

Which is cheaper, Carb Manager or MyFitnessPal Premium?

Carb Manager, on both the monthly and the annual plan; both prices are in the verdict box, checked November 21, 2026 on each vendor’s pricing page. Our product file has no confirmed free tier or free trial for either, so check the sign-up screen before you pay.

What do Carb Manager reviewers complain about most?

Of 200 one- and two-star reviews, 61 mention the price, the paywall or a subscription, and 26 mention logging in, crashes or bugs. Counts are keyword matches, so one review can count under more than one theme.

What do MyFitnessPal reviewers complain about most?

Of 936 one- and two-star reviews, 301 mention the price or paywall and 265 mention an update, with 150 more on logging in or crashes. The same keyword method was used for both apps.

Why are MyFitnessPal's ratings so low?

Reviewers point at paid features and recent updates: 680 of its 1,822 reviews give one star, and 265 of its 936 low ratings mention an update. Its sample only covers August 14 to November 5, 2026, so it reflects how reviewers feel about recent releases.

Did Plate Scales test either app?

No, we do not test apps by hand. This page reports what store reviews, release notes and the store listings say, with counts.

Does Plate Scales earn money from this page?

MyFitnessPal runs an affiliate program on Pepperjam, and our product file lists no paying program for Carb Manager. So the winner here is the app that earns us nothing, and no affiliate link is live on this page yet.

Where do the numbers come from?

Updates log. November 6, 2026: Review counts, percentages and release notes for Carb Manager and MyFitnessPal refreshed from the evidence collected November 6, 2026. Verdicts and winners are unchanged. October 30, 2026: Page drafted from store reviews (1,100 per app) collected October 6, 2026.

How we research. We do not test apps by hand. Pages are researched with AI assistance from app store reviews across versions, release notes and vendor documentation, then edited by William. Method.

Affiliate relationship. Plate Scales earns a commission if you subscribe through links marked as sponsored. Rank order comes from the stated criteria, not from payout. Disclosure.

Health. Plate Scales compares tools. It does not give medical or dietary advice. Health disclaimer.